Best Rental Property Insurance Companies

Landlords are the ones who get insurance for a rental property to secure their house or company structure. Also, it is to secure themselves from such responsibilities wherein someone is injured within their property.  This insurance is comparable to standard property insurance, but it also incorporates other crucial features for enhanced protection.

When you are an owner of a house who wants your house to be rented out or gain a rental property, you will need particular insurance to protect yourself. Selecting the ideal coverage at a reasonable price is essential, but it can be difficult based on the insurance provider you work with.


Based on the specific needs of a landlord, the firm acts as an agent to assist in establishing landlord insurance with a network of different trusted partner carriers. In most areas, GEICO is one of those that offers rental property insurance, which depends on the property location.  Every policy is built based primarily on the replacement cost and location of the home or property, and it covers the house and any additional structures on the land. Policies include coverage of such loss of use, which is the cost of losing rent because of a covered danger like fire. Vacancies during tenant movement are not included, and earthquakes, natural floods, and sewage line blockage are all usual exclusions. Clients can acquire plans with no coverage or premium limits since there is no minimum cost requirement. The firm mainly provides insurance and coverage based on the cost of the replacement of the property.

Some of the best advantages of GEICO are there is no minimum cost, the insurance covers loss of use, and lastly, their policy includes so-called personal property coverage. However, if there is an advantage, there is also a disadvantage, such as they outsource insurance for rental property, and the coverage is based on the cost of replacement.

2. State Farm

This firm is based in Illinois, and they provide the landlord’s insurance through a network of brokers throughout the country. Agents‌ can only insure properties in an area where their office is situated. The price of State Farm homeowner insurance will depend on the replacement cost of the property, liability limitations, and landlord limits. Additional coverage, including other structures and loss of rental revenue, is usually included as a proportion of the housing coverage. State Farm also compensates vacancies if they occur due to a covered danger, such as a disaster or other sort of property damage.

They also do not pay rent loss because of local government restrictions on utilizing properties for short-term rentals. The damages caused by floods and earthquakes are two more typical risks not covered by the standard rental housing policy. Moreover, it does not also cover loss of rent for a reason of inability to pay the mortgage caused by a disability or death. However, this can be protected separately via the insurance of the company.

State Farm’s advantages are they respond quickly, they have an excellent financial rating as well, The coverage is available nationwide, and lastly, they offer discounts for bundling property and auto. On the other hand, the disadvantage is that homeowners must ensure their property for the cost of replacement, and their agents can not currently write such insurance across states.


USAA was established in 1922 in San Antonio, Texas. They currently provide banking and investing services to military personnel, veterans, and their families, besides insurance and annuities. Homeowners who are qualified for membership with USAA can get rental property insurance. With a specific policy, homeowners may cover up to ten rentals and gain protection for the property, lost rental revenue from eligible incidents, and personal liability. When a homeowner merely wants to rent out a portion of their principal dwelling, they can receive specialized home-sharing coverage.

Some of USAA’s advantages are that they can insure up to 10 properties with just one policy, it is also a company that is member-owned. Lastly, their coverage offers are good for the needs of reservists, veterans service members, and their families. However, to get coverage, they must be a member qualified for membership, and ‌ unresponsive.

4. Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual Insurance Company was formed in 1912. Most of their rental property insurance covers up to the cost of replacement, but also, the firm allows owners to insure such properties for the sales price or a certain amount. Their property insurance offers and covers both physical property and the owner’s responsibility for the premise. Landlords can also have additional personal property protection, coverage of the rental value, protection for inflation, as well as disaster coverage within their policies. Flood insurance, like other providers, is not included unless landlords expressly request it, which usually involves purchasing a supplemental policy via the NFIP or National Flood Insurance Program.

Liberty Mutual is a well-established firm. They offer 24 hours claims assistance, and lastly, they insure properties for the cost of replacement, sale price, and more. There is a required additional personal property and rental value.

5. Trusted Choice

A non-profit insurance firm based in the United States is Trusted Choice, created in 2001. Through Trusted Choice, homeowners can compare prices from over 65 leading insurance companies throughout the state with just one application. The cost, coverage, and claims procedure for rental property insurance vary depending on the provider you pick. Still, most plans cover the home itself and the homeowner’s liability in the event of any accidents or injuries and umbrella coverage. There can also be an add-on which is income protection. Homeowners can also purchase an add-on such as flood insurance, workers’ compensation, and inland marine to their Trusted Choice Policy, which may depend on their individual needs.

Most of their advantage is that they have an available network of carriers nationwide that can meet every landlord’s needs. Also, they offer military discounts, safety, group, loyalty, and bundling discounts. Lastly, they have agents who can do quotations from different carriers to get the best deal. However‌, they do not provide direct coverage.

How to Choose the Best Rental Property Insurance?

Rental property insurance, which is also called landlord insurance, will be able to protect you against the hazards of renting out your house or apartment for a very long time. For landlords or homeowners who lease their property, it covers such property damage, liability expenses, and loss of rental revenue.

There are several ways to decide to choose the best rental property insurance that suits you and your property. With that being said, below are the steps to choose the best rental property insurance.

Step 1: Identify the Type of Property You Have

Your actual property type would present distinct packages which can help protect you from occupant-related harm. For instance, the insurance for residential houses may cover such damage to the property, but not the belongings of the tenants. Most business landlords opt to get personal property insurance because items may be rented or used by the tenants.

Step 2: Understanding and Recognizing Landlord Insurance’s Three Basic Types

Landlords’ insurance is divided into three categories:

  • BOP (Business Owners Policy): This kind of insurance would be for landlords which have many sites or buildings with numerous units. A BOP may be thought of as a combination of property insurance and general liability insurance. To put it another way, this form of insurance usually covers both your home and your company against medical claims.
  • CPP (Commercial Packages Policy): Buildings with over 150 units should be employed under Commercial Packages Policy. CPP is very customizable, and you may designate particular dangers in the policy. These policies may be combined with larger coverage options.
  • Fire Insurance Policy: Fire Insurance Policies cover more than just damages caused by fire. It can also cover a wide range of damages such as vandalism, smoke, electrical, and a lot more.

Step 3: Know what you specifically need

After you have determined your property type and your basic insurance coverage, you will need to consider what additional coverage alternatives you could want, such as Inland Marine, Commercial Umbrella, Flood and Earthquake and so much more.

Step 4: Choose a Landlord Insurance Provider or Agent in Your Area

It is important to contact your insurance agent for a quotation after you have a broad notion of the sort of insurance you need. You should include the sort of protection you require, as well as some of the extra policies which could protect you, your company, your property as well as your tenants when you speak with them.

When can you usually purchase Property Insurance?

It is recommended and advisable to search for homeowners insurance the moment you sign a contract to purchase a property.  For a reason, this will give you time to browse around for prices and get your insurance in place before closing on the deal.

Does Rental Property Insurance differ when it comes to Property Type?

Yes. Homeowner’s insurance may include a variety of products such as clothing, furniture, as well as computers, landlord insurance usually only covers items necessary to maintain the rental property. Rental property insurance coverage costs around 25 percent, which is more than a comparable homeowners’ policy for insurance.

Is Rental Property Insurance Required?

No, however, if you do not have landlord insurance, you might probably end up paying out of pocket when something goes wrong. Because your rental property is an important source of revenue, it is ‌essential that you have the coverage to protect it.